Employer Liable for Wrong Tax Code
If you are an employee, you might think that your tax code is important. It is not. It directs how much tax you should pay as you go through the year. It has no bearing on your final tax bill.
If you are an employer, you may think that an employee’s tax code is between them and the taxman and that it has little import to you. You are wrong. You make a mistake with that tax code, and you end up paying the employee’s tax for them.
A recent case before a First Tier Tribunal has found (as many have before them) that the employer should pay the employee’s tax bill, because they applied the tax code incorrectly.
This particular case was wrong because the ‘week/month 1’ criterion was not used. On payroll software, it is a tickbox. Tickboxes can be missed, they can be hit twice and so become unticked. Once the mistake is made, you would never look at it again. Sadly, the taxman does when it comes to the end of the tax year and finds an underpayment of tax.
HMRC can come after you straightaway. In this case, they went for the employee. It is after all, their tax bill. The employee took HMRC to Tribunal and won. HMRC are ok with losing this one, because the Tribunal simply directs that the employer pays, as it is their mistake.
I don’t see this as fair and equitable. It is because it is so unfair, that I bring it to your attention. You can end up paying someone else’s tax for them if you make a simple and honest mistake.
Get the detail right, or better still, don’t employ people.