r
_

A Diary is Private

HMRC’s right to inspect a sole trader’s business diary has been dismissed by the First-tier Tribunal.

The particular case was a doctor who provided cosmetic treatments.

HMRC asked to have a look inside and the taxpayer refused, arguing that it held no financial information.

The Tribunal ruled that in this case the diary “was not necessarily an accurate record of patients seen and services provided or charged for”.  It was satisfied that there was no way of correlating the numbers of patients with the turnover generated.

I am not saying that this defence will work in all cases, but you should certainly at least consider whether this ruling could apply to you if you find yourself subject to a HMRC request to look at your work diary.

 

Share