VAT and a Scary Retrospective Registration Case
A recent VAT tribunal case has found against the taxpayer and turned her into a VATpayer, as well.
Our hero argued that she was merely acting as a broker or agent in introducing cleaners and tradesmen to owners of holiday lets. If she was properly an agent, then she would not have had a contract with the customer and would therefore be classed as receiving turnover from tradesmen. These commissions would have kept her underneath the VAT threshold.
The tribunal disagreed with her opinion, reaching their own conclusion that the way she engaged with her customer and suppliers meant that she was buying in and selling on.
There are two lessons, here.
Firstly, be wary of how your business actually operates and looks if you want to argue that you are only an agent.
Secondly, the VATman took her retrospective registration back to 1999 in this case! They can go back 20 years in registration orders! Add interest and penalties on top and you are looking at catastrophic numbers.