r
_

Get Your Paperwork Right

It matters not what you think the reality is.  In disputes with the taxman, it matters what it looks like to the outside world.

A recent case before the Tribunal found against the taxpayer in their appeal that a property sale should be treated as a trading rather than a capital sale.  We have to assume there was a bigger tax bill under capital gains tax.

The taxpayer maintained that it had always been his intention to buy, do up and sell the building in keeping with his normal trade in buying, developing and selling property.  He had no paperwork or any other evidence that backed up his version of events.  To the outside world, he bought the property and then let it out for 4 years before selling on.  That makes it look like an asset held for its investment potential = capital.

For lessons learned from this case, it is irrelevant what the loser’s intentions really were.  What we learn from this is that if there is room for the taxman to reach an alternative interpretation of the facts, and it matters to you what he thinks, you must make sure you document evidence to support your version.

Share