Tribunal Rules HMRC Penalties Unfair
This particular ruling relates to CIS late filing penalties, but the principle would apply to any.
This is not good news for public services, but it is good news for individuals who are being mugged by HMRC in their quest to replace lost income-related tax-take with penalties.
In the case just ruled upon, HMRC initially levied £54,000 penalties on an unsuspecting construction industry contractor for late monthly returns on which the tax concerned was just £6,000.
Upon appeal, HMRC itself reduced the penalties to £19,000 – always worth staring the bullies down, themselves.
Not satisfied, the contractor took HMRC to a tribunal. It ruled that the penalties were “not merely harsh but … plainly unfair”. It reduced the level of penalties to £6,000 – the scale of the tax involved in the returns sent in late.
This is not the first time that tribunals have found against HMRC on their system of excessive penalties and shows that it is worth a challenge if you end up being the one picked on to swell the public purse.