“Unfair” Grounds for Appeal Against VAT Default Surcharge
A number of tribunal appeals brought by the oppressed taxpayer have been successful where the VAT payment was just one day late and the disproportionality of the one-day-late offence measured against the level of penalty was such that the tribunal had no option but to agree that the penalty was “plainly unfair”.
This does not give you much scope, as it restricts appeals to cases of one day late and also the measure of “unfairness” is a little at odds with what you might think.
Tribunals have rejected appeals that are merely “harsh”.
When I was growing up, banter was often described as “harsh but fair”. This would descibe all manner of vicious put-downs and assaults on one’s character. Seems that my old school mates must be sitting on these tribunals.
Examples of when tribunals have had to agree that penalties are unfair are a £131,881 surcharge that represented 1825% interest and a £4k surcharge for a small company with only £50k annual profits. Both cases were just one day late.
Lesson is that you never just accept what HM’s finest robbers first say. Wriggling your way clear of their evil clutches is not easy, but this is one of a number of angles open to you.