r
_

Another Decision on Proportionality of VAT Penalties

This is a tricky one for me. By nature, I like to be able to take a side.  I love sport not for the beauty of the game, but for the partisanship that it allows. In business, I kind of thought that any victory against HMRC was sweet.  They are, after all, robbing bastards of the highest order. Now, I find a victory at Tribunal over HMRC, but the victor is a newspaper group.  Booo.  That’s 2 things wrong with our society in the same ‘match’: HMRC and tabloid newspapers.  Who to support..? On reflection, I am happy to cheer the victory of Trinity Mirror plc because it will set a precedent that the rest of us can take advantage of in the future. The dispute was over a £95,900 penalty for being a day late with their VAT return.  HMRC’s computer charged the penalty.  Trinity Mirror held up the EU VAT Directive that binds HMRC to have regard to proportionality of the penalty to the gravity of the offence committed.  (Hurrah for the EU).  HMRC stood by their penalty regime and insisted that £95,900 was collectible because they were one day late. Well, if the EU are our heroes here, then the First Tier Tribunal are superheroes.  They applied the law and some common sense in that the penalty did not fit the crime. Rather splendidly, the Tribunal does not have the power to mitigate a penalty and so the whole thing was quashed. So, our lesson in all of this should not be learning who the good guys are.  It is that if you get a VAT penalty that turns your stomach sick to its core because of how unfair it is, consider whether this case could help you argue disproportionality before a Tribunal.

Share