It’s All In The Wording
We see this so many times in tax law. It’s not so much about what you meant to say. It matters what you actually did say.
A simple warranty in a simple purchase and sale agreement went to court with the taxpayer appealing HMRC’s decision to refuse capital gains tax relief on a warranty payment. HMRC won.
The warranty was given by the directors, while the shares were sold by the shareholders. That the directors were the shareholders was not going to deter HMRC from applying the strict letter of the tax law and the Upper Tier Tribunal were powerless to stop them.
So, the owner sold his business and paid tax on the whole amount received. He later paid out on a warranty claim and was not able to have that payment deducted from his tax computation.
It was all because the warranty was worded to have been given by the directors and it was not they who were making the chargeable gain. Well, it was… but then again, it wasn’t. You see, it’s all in the wording. Make sure you get it right.