r
_

Tax Case – Reminder that HMRC Not Always Right + Tip on Incorporating a Property Letting

A taxpayer has just won on appeal their right to capital gains tax relief on the incorporation of their property letting business.

There are many factors to consider when deciding whether to own investment property in a company.  The most valuable of these tend to be between the rate of tax you pay on the profits (40%? if held personally vs 20% in a company), and the tax you would pay on any gain on sale (a company has no annual exemption from capital gains).

As circumstances change, so do the arguments for whether you should hold property personally or in a company.  If you decide that a property in personal names should now be in a company, you have a problem or two with transferring it into a company.  There is no way around stamp duty land tax, but capital gains tax can be avoided, or at least deferred.  At least that’s what we all thought, until HMRC decided to use taxpayers money to try and argue that property rental is not a business and can therefore not make use of incorporation holdover relief.  Even more galling was that the First Tier Tribunal agreed with HMRC.  Thankfully, the taxpayer took it all the way and won at the Upper Tribunal which restored some common sense to the world.  Property letting is a business – full stop.

So, now you know a bit more about incorporating a property lettings business and a lot more about how HMRC waste public money on vindictive attempts to take tax where it is not due and even more about how you can stand up to them and you can find someone who will tell them that they’re wrong.

Share