r
_

Previous Good Behaviour Backing Up a Reasonable Excuse

A Tribunal has just upheld an appeal by a taxpayer against HMRC’s removal of his CIS gross payment status.

Our hero had a previous good record.

He then suffered a series of major events in both his personal and business life that created cash flow difficulties, leading directly to the failure to pay his taxes on time.  One such event listed in the court documents was the reduction by the bank of his overdraft.

HMRC also chose to kick the man when he was down and compel his customers to deduct CIS tax at source.

The Tribunal put the taxman in his place.  Sadly, they have no such powers over the banks.  They found that he had acted as a reasonably competent businessman in circumstances which he could not have foreseen and which were beyond his control.  They also noted his good compliance record prior to his problems.

So, if the taxman comes after you and you think you have a reasonable excuse, backed by a good historic record, remember there are some good guys left.  They sit on Tribunals.

Share