Principal Private Residence Relief from Capital Gains Tax – Burden of Proof
Everyone knows and accepts that if you have one house that you live in and then sell it for a gain, CGT does not apply.
There are a number of grey areas where you have more than one house or you lived in one for a time before renting it out and then selling later on.
With the Capital Gains Act allowing for a fair portion of the gain to be relieved for the time you lived in it + the last 3 years given free + lettings relief, it can be very tax-advantageous to have lived in a house that you later make a gain on.
Many years after you have moved out, it can be very difficult to prove that you occupied the house as your main residence.
A recent tax case reminds us that the burden of proof is on the taxpayer. The Tribunal referred to the said occupier not having notified relevant authorities, banks, employer etc that he was living there while post continued to be sent to his old address.
In the Tribunal’s own words, future claims for PPR in grey areas will need to have demonstrated to the wider world the taxpayer’s ties with the property: “In order to show that occupation in any particular case amounts to residence with the requisite degree of permanence, some degree of continuity or some expectation of continuity, it must be expected that the taxpayer in question should have taken some steps to demonstrate to the “wider world” his ties with the property which he is claiming has become his only or main residence. Any individual factor such as notifying change of address, registering to vote from the new address or basing applications for credit cards at that address is not necessarily a pre-requisite for this purpose, but the overall picture must be consistent with the proposition that the taxpayer has moved his base from where he has previously been living and established it at that new address.”
So if you do actually live in a house and then own it at the same time as another, make sure you have evidence in support of any future claim for PPR. They won’t just take your word for it.