A Company Car is Provided by Reason of Employment
Tax is enforced by legislation. Law is all down to the wording.
Company car tax is worded to capture any car provided to the employee by “reason of employment”.
The same wording is used to police the benefits of low or zero interest loans from employers to employees. There is protection for employees of employers whose business it is to lend money in that the law states that no benefit shall arise when the low rate of interest is attached to a product that is widely available to the public. In other words, the employee secures the rate of interest for some other reason than being an employee.
I now want to use the same wording of legislation and look at our tip of yesterday that an employee can’t simply reimburse the cost of a car lease.
Suppose the employer pays £300 a month to lease a car and asks the employee to pay £325 a month. Suppose everyone likes this arrangement and lots of employees in lots of different divisions take up this offer. Suppose the employer makes a few quid out of it. Suppose then that the employer makes the scheme available to non-employees in pursuit of profit. You then have the provision of a car for some reason other than employment = no company car tax.
This exact scenario was played out in a tax case last month where a Tribunal ruled that the car was provided to the employee on a commercial basis and the provision was not dependent on the person being an employee = no company car tax.
I would not necessarily recommend such an effort to avoid company car tax, but if you are desperate to have the employer lease the car and the employee avoid tax by paying for its cost, then this is your only hope.