Tax Consequences of Termination Agreements
A recent tax case reminds us that we all need to have regard to tax when drawing up compromise agreements.
Johnson vs HMRC is a tale of a £75700 pay-off at termination of employment contract. The intention was for this to include the repayment of a £30000 share option that the employee had previously invested into the employer. So, how it should have worked is £30k straight repayment of investment + £30k tax-free redundancy payment + £15700 taxable.
Not sure exactly what happened here with the wording of the agreement, but the emphasis is very often on protecting the employer from any come-back by the employee. For example, in “full and final settlement of all sums due to the employee by the employer” etc.
HMRC slyly spotted the wording suggested that the compensation payment was purely relating to his role as an employee and not in part a repayment of investment. They very nearly won and the taxpayer (while in the right) only got off on a technicality.
So, the tip for today is to think carefully about the tax consequences of the words in your contracts and agreements. You may know the intentions of what you agree, but the taxman will only have the documents to go by.