Fight HMRC All The Way
Yesterday’s stunning piece of news is the HMRC are not always right.
Having given you time to absorb this, I now want you to remember to stand up and fight them when you believe you are right and they are wrong.
You are entitled to appeal their decisions and the HM Tribunals system exists to rule on disputes between taxpayer and taxtaker.
This system is largely just.
One case that is just appearing is that of a decision by HMRC to disallow a claim as a deduction against profits for repairs to a road. HMRC sometimes forget wrong and right an only think about seeking to maximise the tax-take. They said no to the repairs, claiming instead that the expenditure was on improving the land and therefore not incurred in pursuit of trade. It is the old ‘revenue vs capital’ debate that will be relevant to many of you at some points in your business lives. HMRC was wrong. They misinterpreted one of the rules of ‘revenue vs capital’ and the Tribunal agreed with the taxpayer that the repair brought the asset to a modern expected standard – it didn’t improve it.
So, if you believe you’re right and HMRC is wrong, then take them to Tribunal.